Science with NIFS, Australia's First Gemini Instrument

Peter J. McGregor , Michael Dopita , Peter Wood , Michael G. Burton, PASA, 18 (1), in press.

Next Section: Context
Title/Abstract Page: Science with NIFS, Australia's
Previous Section: NIFS Core Science
Contents Page: Volume 18, Number 1

Subsections



Gemini Core Science


Brown Dwarfs and Low Mass Stars

Recent near-infrared sky surveys have succeeded in identifying large numbers of low mass stars and brown dwarfs. However, objects in binary systems still offer the only means of empirically determining precise masses and absolute magnitudes for this class of object. These data are basic to an understanding of the low mass stellar and substellar mass function, and ultimately the transfer of angular momentum during star formation and the universal proportion of matter bound up in sub-stellar companions. The distances to objects in binary systems can be determined, so they provide empirical calibration of the color versus absolute magnitude relation that can be applied to field and cluster brown dwarf candidates. NIFS with occulting disks will record moderate resolution near-infrared spectra of the close companions that will provide effective temperatures and other physical parameters for the companions. The imaging capability of NIFS will be invaluable in removing the complex residual ``speckle'' pattern of the bright primary star.

Spectra in the J, H, and K bands with a resolving power of $R \sim 1000$ are sufficient to determine molecular absorption band strengths for temperature determination (e.g., Gl229B; Geballe et al. 1996; $K \sim 14.8$ mag). The central star can be used as the ALTAIR guide star in all conceivable cases. Finding a nearby OIWFS guide star will be subject to random field statistics.

The performance of NIFS in detecting binary companions has been assessed by determining the signal-to-noise ratio that will be achieved in spectra obtained with the K grating and smoothed to a two-pixel resolving power of $R \sim$ 1000. The image obtained from a simulated NIFS observation of a K = 12 mag primary and K = 18 mag secondary by collapsing the data in the spectral direction is shown in Figure 3. The R = 1000 sky-subtracted spectrum of the secondary star is shown in Figure 4 (ignoring point spread function uncertainties and residual speckle structure in the primary star profile). These simulations predict that NIFS will saturate using the K grating in 1800 s on a $K \sim$ 12 mag primary star in 0.4'' seeing with a Strehl ratio of 0.6. A signal-to-noise ratio of $\sim $ 18 will be achieved in the R = 1000 spectrum of a 0.5'' offset companion star with K = 18 mag in this time. Integration times will be limited to 15 s on a K = 7 mag primary star. The signal-to-noise ratio achieved on an 18 mag secondary in a total integration time of 1800 s is then $\sim $ 4.

Figure 3: Simulated collapsed NIFS image showing a K = 18 mag companion star 0.5'' to the left of a K = 12 mag primary star in 0.4'' seeing with a Strehl ratio of 0.6. The exposure time with the K grating is 1800 s which just saturates the K = 12 mag star.
\begin{figure} \centering\leavevmode \epsfysize=100mm \epsfbox{sim_bin_k1218i.ps}\end{figure}

Figure 4: Spectrum of the K = 18 mag M1III star companion in Figure 3 smoothed to a two-pixel resolving power of R = 1000. Atmospheric absorption features have been removed by division by a smooth spectrum star.
\begin{figure} \centering\leavevmode \epsfysize=100mm \epsfbox{sim_bin_k1218s.ps}\end{figure}


Young Star Clusters

A knowledge of the stellar initial mass function over the full range of masses from the Eddington limit to below the hydrogen-burning limit, and its dependence on environment, are fundamental to an understanding of the star formation process. The upper stellar mass cut-off needs to be explored in nearby regions of massive star formation in order to better understand the nature of massive star formation occurring in more extreme regions such as starburst galaxies. Concentrations of high mass stars are found in young Galactic star clusters. These are often obscured by dust due to their youth or their large distances from Earth. High spatial resolution observations are needed to probe the cores of dense star clusters associated with Galactic giant H II regions (e.g., Blum, Damineli, & Conti 1999) and clusters in the vicinity of the Galactic center (e.g., Cotera et al. 1996). The physical parameters of embedded massive stars can be derived from high signal-to-noise ratio ($\sim $ 70), moderate resolution (R > 1000) spectra in the H and K bands (Blum, Damineli, & Conti 1999; Hanson, Howarth, & Conti 1997; Hanson, Conti, & Rieke 1996).

Knowledge of the low mass end of the stellar initial mass function in different environments is needed to determine the amount of Galactic mass locked up in low mass stars, to understand chemical enrichment and recycling in galaxies, and to determine the impact of starbursts on galaxy evolution. Most low mass stars currently forming in the Galaxy appear to be forming in star clusters associated with giant molecular clouds (Lada et al. 1991). Stellar masses for lower mass pre-main-sequence stars ($M < 5 M_\odot$) cannot be determined unambiguously from broadband near-infrared photometry alone due to the indeterminate effects of interstellar extinction and the nature of their evolutionary tracks. Moderate resolution K band spectra of these obscured, low mass, cluster pre-main-sequence stars are required to assign them spectroscopic temperatures (Hodapp & Deane 1993; Luhman & Rieke 1998), and hence infer their masses based on evolutionary tracks.

Source confusion and the irregular backgrounds from complex reflection and emission nebulosity associated with dense young star clusters make slit spectroscopy of faint, embedded, young stars difficult. NIFS with its IFU will allow more accurate removal of these irregular backgrounds. The compact W43 cluster (Blum, Damineli, & Conti 1999) contains stars measured photometrically to $K \sim 16$ mag, corresponding to a spectral type of $\sim $ A0 on the main sequence. NIFS will be capable of measuring K band spectra of these stars with $R \sim 5000$ and signal-to-noise ratios of $\sim 40$ in 1800 s.


YSO Jet Driving Mechanism

The driving mechanism for outflows from young stellar objects (YSOs) has not been observationally identified. Shocked, collimated jets are seen at large distances from the star, but the properties of the winds at their origins, and even the mass loss rates, remain uncertain and model dependent. High spatial resolution spectral imaging in emission lines probing shocked gas, such as H2 1-0 S(1) 2.122 $\mu $m and [Fe II] 1.644 $\mu $m, will allow observation of the energetic, highly collimated jets as they emerge from the inner regions of the accretion disks. The high spectral resolution of NIFS, relative to narrow-band line filters, will enable better discrimination against continuum emission making NIFS the preferred Gemini instrument for near-infrared spectral imaging of faint, narrow emission line sources. High resolution spectral imaging of YSO jets with NIFS will provide simultaneous morphological, excitation, and kinematic data which, over time, will allow the evolution of features in these stellar jets to be traced as they progress along the jet and interact with the surrounding material. Such observations are crucial to understanding the role played by high energy outflows in terminating infall and determining the final stellar mass. For example, a ``Herbig-Haro'' emission knot located in a nearby dark cloud $\sim $ 150 pc from Earth and moving at 100 km s-1 traverses 0.13'' in one year. Proper motions of such Herbig-Haro knots could be followed over a 2-3 yr period, allowing the acceleration mechanism to be probed as well as the interaction of these knots with the ambient cloud. Temporal variations in an extremely young Herbig-Haro flow ejected from XZ Tau have been seen in the optical with HST (Krist et al. 1999). Emission line spectroscopy of such features with NIFS will reveal details of how the flows expand and evolve.

The targeted emission lines will be the H2 lines in the K band and [Fe II] 1.644 $\mu $m in the H band. The H2 1-0 S(1) 2.122 $\mu $m and H2 1-0 Q(3) 2.424 $\mu $m emission lines arise from the same J=3 upper level so their flux ratio can be used to derive the interstellar extinction correction. This is one motivation for extending the NIFS K grating response to the edge of the atmospheric window near 2.5 $\mu $m. These observations require the highest possible spatial resolution and velocity resolutions in the H and K bands of 50-100 km s-1. Velocity centroids can be determined to

$\Delta{v} \sim$ FWHM/SNR which should be $\sim $ 5-10 km s-1with typical signal-to-noise ratios. Visible T Tauri stars can be used as natural guide stars for ALTAIR, when available, but a different star will be required for the OIWFS. The near-infrared response of the NIFS OIWFS will greatly increase the availability of suitable OIWFS stars in star formation regions. Many YSOs are either not visible objects or are resolved in the optical. Laser guide stars will be essential for AO corrected observations of these stars.


YSO Jet-Cloud Interactions

YSO outflows remove excess angular momentum from the protostar system, they contribute to the turbulent support of molecular clouds, and they may be responsible for disrupting molecular clouds and ultimately terminating star formation within them. YSO outflows generally consist of a highly collimated, high velocity bipolar jet embedded in a less well collimated low velocity bipolar molecular outflow that is detected at millimeter wavelengths. The physical parameters of the highly collimated YSO jets are still incompletely understood. They emit most strongly in shock-excited transitions of H2 and [Fe II] in the near-infrared, and low excitation emission lines typical of Herbig-Haro objects in the optical in regions where the jet material impacts the surrounding medium. A bow shock forms where shocked gas impacts quiescent material in front of a Mach disk which forms where the jet impacts previously shocked material. Observed emission line strengths can be modeled either as J-shocks, C-shocks, or a combination of the two (e.g., Buckle, Hatchell, & Fuller 1999). J-shocks occur where the magnetic field is weak and cause the gas properties to change suddenly. C-shocks occur in the presence of a strong magnetic field. A C-shock can form at the bow shock and a J-shock can form at the Mach disk when the magnetic field is intermediate in strength. Which type of shock applies in YSO jet-cloud interactions is still controversial. The relative emission line strengths give an indication of the type and speed of the shock (Smith 1995). The bow shock and Mach disk are expected to be separated by $\sim $ 500 AU ($\sim 3.4''$ at 150 pc) in most cases (Hartigan 1989), but the curved structure of the bow shock complicates identification of this feature. High spatial resolution spectral imaging with NIFS may succeed in separating these components.

YSO jets often have a knotty appearance, possibly due to jet instabilities or episodic ejection. Emission arising from between the knots may be due to the jet being partially molecular, due to entrainment of ambient material in a mixing layer, or simply due to the existence of unresolved emission knots. YSO jets have many similarities (and differences) with relativistic jets emanating from radio galaxies. Understanding the physical processes occurring in YSO jets may also help in understanding the nature of these extragalactic jets.

Spatially resolved NIFS spectra in the K band are needed to determine H2 emission line fluxes, flux ratios, and radial velocities. Proper motions are also needed for knots within the jet to test jet models quantitatively. Typical jet velocities are $\sim $ 200 km s-1. Projected velocities are correspondingly lower, so velocity resolutions of $\sim $ 50 km s-1 are required. Optical AO guide stars may be scarce in dark clouds, making laser guide star observations highly beneficial. It will be possible to use nearby embedded stars as the near-infrared OIWFS guide star in many cases.


Late Stages of Stellar Evolution

In recent years, HST and deep ground-based imaging of asymptotic giant branch (AGB) stars, proto-planetary nebulae, and young planetary nebulae have revealed remarkable but previously unknown structures. These show exquisite detail of central, point symmetric, often bipolar, cavities being carved out of the centers of spherical AGB star mass-loss envelopes (Sahai et al. 1998; Sahai et al. 1999a,b; Sahai & Trauger 1998). How such non-spherical cavities can be produced inside the recent spherical AGB star mass-loss wind is an unsolved mystery. Binarity, rotation, and magnetic fields have all been suggested. Most importantly, it is the immediate post-AGB phase where the asymmetries develop, so it is here that we should look for objects beginning the aspherical mass-loss process. Samples of candidate objects are currently being examined from the ground (e.g., van der Steene & Wood 1999, priv. comm.): they often show H$\alpha $ emission with a central peak of width $\sim $ 100 km s-1, a P Cygni type absorption on the blue edge of the emission line, and broad wings with widths of order 1000 km s-1. High spatial and spectral resolution observations of these objects are required in order to examine the gas dynamical processes occurring in them. In particular, K band observations in the lines of H2 1-0 S(1) 2.122 $\mu $m and H I Br$\gamma$ 2.166 $\mu $m are required in order to study the beginning of cavity generation (as evidenced by H2 emission from shocked gas) and to determine the location of the H II region: is it a wind from the AGB star remnant, is it a jet from an accretion disk around a companion star, do the broad 1000 km s-1 and 100 km s-1 components of the H I lines come from the same place spatially? Velocity resolutions of a few km s-1 are required for this work in order to make models of the gas flows in these systems. Since the H2 emission has been detected by NICMOS, it should be measurable with NIFS. Many proto-planetary nebulae and most young planetary nebulae have central stars that can be used as guide stars for ALTAIR. OIWFS guide stars will be subject to random field statistics.


Galactic Center

The Galactic center is a unique region of the Galaxy populated by old stars constituting the inner Galactic bulge as well as young clusters of massive stars indicative of recent intense star formation activity. There is now strong evidence for the existence of a central massive black hole in the Galactic center (Eckart & Genzel 1996, 1997; Genzel et al. 1997; Ghez et al. 1998). High spatial and moderate spectral resolution observations of stars in the vicinity of the black hole are required to determine their radial velocity dispersion to complement available high spatial resolution proper motion data, and to study the nature of the stellar population. Stars close to the black hole should interact with the black hole and with each other frequently and may show evidence for these interactions in their spectral or morphological properties. Understanding the star formation history of the central region of the Galaxy will lead to a clearer understanding of the formation of the Galactic bulge, the nature of star formation in an environment of extreme gas temperature, pressure, velocity dispersion, magnetic field strength, and tidal shear, and of the processes fueling the central black hole in our Galaxy and perhaps in other more active galaxies.

The Galactic center is obscured at wavelengths shorter than $\sim $ 1.5 $\mu $m. Most of the bright stars detected in the K band are young late-type supergiant and asymptotic giant branch stars or older luminous red giant stars. Main sequence stars are intrinsically fainter in the near-infrared, and so are more difficult to detect. Nevertheless, main sequence stars in the volume around the Galactic center are being found in deep photometric surveys using conventional techniques (e.g., Blum, Sellgren, & DePoy 1996) and AO image correction (Davidge et al. 1997b). Near-infrared spectra are needed for significant samples of faint stars in the crowded Galactic center region in order to estimate effective temperatures, extinctions, luminosities, and hence masses and ages. NIFS will be well-suited to this task (Figure 5); the spectral resolution, spatial resolution, sensitivity, and ability to accurately characterize complex background emission are all essential. Techniques for spectrally classifying early-type stars based on high signal-to-noise ratio $R \sim 1000$ H band and K band spectra are now in place (e.g., Ali et al. 1995; Blum et al. 1997; Hanson, Rieke, & Luhman 1998). Higher spectral resolving powers of R > 3000 are required for radial velocity measurements of stars in the immediate vicinity of the central massive black hole. Present AO corrected imaging (Davidge et al. 1997b) extends to $K \sim 16$ mag. Early-type main sequence stars are expected at K > 14 mag. High signal-to-noise ratio spectra of these stars can be measured with NIFS in $\sim $ 1 hr per field. High Strehl ratios are essential to separate individual stars in this crowded region. A star with R = 13.9 mag (``star A'') is located 18.8'' from Sgr A* and can be used as the AO guide star for observations of the central region. A range of near-infrared-bright OIWFS guide stars exist.

Figure 5: K band image of the Galactic center region (Eckart et al. 1995) centered on Sgr A*, the central black hole, with the NIFS field-of-view ( square grid) superposed. The axis units are arcseconds on the sky.
\begin{figure} \centering\leavevmode \epsfysize=100mm \epsfbox{gc.ps}\end{figure}


Nuclear Stellar Populations in Local Group Galaxies

Little is known about the nuclear stellar populations in Local Group galaxies. Near-infrared spectra of nuclear stellar populations obtained with NIFS will provide information on the stellar content and star formation histories of nearby galaxies. The nucleus of M31 is known to be double (Lauer et al. 1993) and consist of separate red and blue brightness peaks. The massive black hole is believed to reside within the blue peak, P2. This appears to be the nuclear star cluster but its stellar content and star formation history remain unclear. The dynamical state of the red peak, P1, is mysterious. The instability timescale for a star cluster in this environment is $\sim 10^4$ yr indicating that additional stabilizing influences must be at play. Tremaine (1995) suggested that the brightness peak at P1 can be explained as the apogalactica of stars orbiting P2 in an eccentric disk. A similar double nucleus is present in another massive black hole galaxy, NGC 4486B (Lauer et al. 1996), and blue nuclear star clusters similar to P2 occur in the Local Group late-type galaxies M33 (e.g., Kormendy & McClure 1993) and IC 342 (Böker, van der Marel, & Vacca 1999). Many parallels exist between these Local Group nuclear star clusters and the Milky Way nuclear star cluster. Infrared spectra in combination with optical and ultraviolet spectra of these blue nuclear star clusters in Local Group galaxies provide insight into the reddening, mass, and age of the starbursts that have formed them or recently activated them (e.g., Gordon et al. 1999; Böker et al.).


Old Stellar Populations in Nearby Galaxies

ALTAIR on Gemini will resolve stars in nearby galaxies and hence make their stellar populations accessible to photometric and spectroscopic study. Asymptotic giant branch stars in several nearby galaxies have been studied photometrically in the optical with WFPC2 on HST. These photometric studies have only recently been extended to the near-infrared with AO systems on ground-based 4 m telescopes (e.g., the nucleus of M31; Davidge et al. 1997a). Source confusion remains a problem with 0.15'' spatial resolution in the central regions of even nearby galaxies. The smaller diffraction-limited images with ALTAIR on Gemini will alleviate much of this problem. However, the high Strehl ratios that are required will restrict these observations to the near-infrared. At infrared wavelengths, the stellar population is dominated by asymptotic giant branch and red giant branch stars. Near-infrared spectra of individual stars will provide information that will lead to a better understanding of the chemical abundances and abundance ranges of stars in Local Group galaxies. The CO 2-0 absorption bands at 2.3 $\mu $m are the primary abundance indicator in late-type stars. The 1.62 $\mu $m feature, due mainly to CO 6-3 absorption, has also been used in late-type stars with [Fe/H] $\geq$ -1.3 (Origlia et al. 1997).

Studies of asymptotic giant branch stars should reach to $M_K \sim -7.0$ mag, or $K \sim 17.5$ mag at the distance of M31 and its dwarf elliptical satellite galaxy, M32 ($m-M \sim 24.5$ mag). These are among the brightest old stars in these galaxies. NIFS with ALTAIR will achieve a signal-to-noise ratio in the K band of $\sim $ 10 per pixel in 1800 s with R = 5340 at the asymptotic giant branch tip. Smoothing to R = 1000, which is adequate for CO band studies, will increase the signal-to-noise ratio to $\sim 23$ per pixel. The central 2.8'' diameter nuclear region of M31 contains $\sim 20$ objects with K = 14.5-16.5 mag detected with AO imaging (Davidge et al. 1997a). These stars are exceptionally bright and are either a separate population of young massive stars (as in our galaxy), or they are unresolved star clusters. The tip of the red giant branch in globular cluster-like populations similar to 47 Tuc occurs at $M_K \sim -5.0$ mag (Frogel, Persson, & Cohen 1981), corresponding to $K \sim 19.5$ mag at the distance of M31 and M32. K band observations of these stars at R = 1000 will require integration times of $\sim $ 2.5 hr to reach a signal-to-noise ratio of $\sim $ 10 per pixel. The success of these observations will depend critically on the Strehl ratio achieved; high Strehl ratios increase signal-to-noise ratio and reduce source confusion which will be severe at these fainter magnitudes. The star count models of Ratnatunga & Bahcall (1985) predict that there will be $\sim $ 0.3 star arcmin-2 with R < 16.5 mag along the sight-line to M31 and M32, assuming a typical B-R color of 0.5, so there should be $\sim $ 1 suitable AO guide star per 2' diameter ALTAIR field in this direction. Observations will be restricted to regions within $\sim 15''$ of these AO guide stars. Spatial information obtained with the NIFS IFU will aid accurate background removal.

High signal-to-noise ratio, moderate resolution spectra are required for detailed chemical abundance studies. At the full resolution available with the K grating, a signal-to-noise ratio of 100 will be obtained in 1 hr on a star with $K \sim 15.0$ mag. Thus it will be possible with NIFS to obtain full resolution K band spectra of red giant branch tip stars with m-M < 20, or distances < 100 kpc. This will enable detailed chemical abundance analyses of red giant branch tip stars in local dwarf galaxies and in the Galactic halo. These spectra will also provide dynamical information.


Nearby Starburst Galaxies and Starburst Regions

Nearby starburst galaxies are excellent laboratories for studying the dissipation processes that are believed to have occurred when galaxy spheroids formed. The dominant structural components of nearby starburst galaxies have now been spatially resolved in the ultraviolet and optical with HST; WFPC2 images reveal large numbers of ``super star clusters'' which resemble young, massive (105-106 $M_\odot$) globular clusters and which have properties more extreme than those of 30 Dor in the Large Magellanic Cloud, for example. Near-Infrared ground-based observations (e.g., NGC 1808; Tacconi-Garman, Sternberg, & Eckart 1996) identify presumably young ``super star clusters'' embedded in dust with $A_V \sim$ 10-20 mag. These optically hidden ``super star clusters'' may contain the youngest and most massive stars. Studying individual ``super star clusters'' spectroscopically in the near-infrared will allow starburst models to be applied to specific coeval components of the overall starburst. The distribution of interstellar extinction in starburst regions affects our interpretation of starburst energetics. Measuring extinction indicators on spatial scales comparable to the dominant starburst structures will improve our ability to distinguish between foreground screen and mixed extinction models for these components, leading to more accurate interpretations. Comparison of the ages and star formation rates derived for different locations within the starburst will reveal how the starburst has progressed through the region.

Typical continuum and emission line surface brightnesses can be estimated from knots in the starburst ring of NGC 7552 (Schinnerer et al. 1997). The K band continuum surface brightnesses are $K \sim$ 13.0-13.5 mag arcsec-2, and the prominent emission line surface brightnesses are $\sim $ 8-25

x 10-23 W cm-2 arcsec-2. Emission lines with surface brightnesses of

$\sim 14 \times 10^{-23}$ W cm-2 arcsec-2 and FWHM $\sim $ 100 km s-1 should be measured with NIFS to a signal-to-noise ratio of 10 in 1800 s with

0.1'' x 0.1'' spatial resolution. A mosaic of 3 x 3 NIFS fields would be needed to fully map the starburst ring and nucleus of NGC 7552.


Ultra-Luminous Infrared Galaxies

Ultra-luminous infrared galaxies (ULIRGs) occur in the late phases of the merger of two or more gas-rich galaxies. They may be the merger remnants of former compact galaxy groups (Borne et al. 2000). They have massive ($\sim 10^{10}$ $M_\odot$; Solomon et al. 1997), dense (

$n_{H_2} \geq 10^4$ cm-3; Solomon, Downes, & Radford 1992) concentrations of molecular gas and dust in their central regions and are powered by either intense, compact starbursts or AGN activity. Their luminosities (> 1012 $L_\odot$), space density, activity, and short evolutionary timescales ($\sim 10^8$ yr) suggest that they may represent an early phase in the formation of quasars (Sanders et al. 1988). Double nuclei with subarcsecond separations are seen in several well-studied examples. These are interpreted as the remnant nuclei of the merged galaxies. Several ULIRGs have K light profiles that are well-fitted with a r1/4 de Vaucouleurs law suggesting that elliptical galaxies will be the end result of the mergers (Wright et al. 1990; Doyon et al. 1994) and that their high central mass densities are comparable to those of elliptical galaxies (Kormendy & Sanders 1992); ULIRGs may be analogs of proto-elliptical galaxies formed at high redshift. They are currently undergoing dissipative collapse which may also be analogous to spheroid formation in disk galaxies.

High angular resolution spectral imaging with NIFS will probe the stellar populations and emission line characteristics on spatial scales commensurate with the nuclear separations. These data will provide information on star formation rates, starburst lifetimes, and the nature of the stellar initial mass function close to the compact luminosity sources as well as information on the gas dynamics in the region where the nuclei interact. Velocity dispersion data can be used to derive mass estimates for the enclosed regions. Both emission line and stellar absorption-line diagnostics can be used for this purpose. Extending these studies to smaller radii will place tighter constraints on the compact luminosity sources. Millimeter molecular line data with 0.5'' resolution for Arp 220, for example, suggest that the double nuclei are each surrounded by counter-rotating gas disks with radial extents of $\sim 0.3''$ (Sakamoto et al. 1999). The formation of nuclear gas disks during galaxy mergers may be a natural consequence of the high dissipation rates in dense gas. However, the likely role these disks play in driving nuclear starbursts or fueling AGN activity is yet to be explored. Interaction between these disks should be apparent in near-infrared shock-excited emission lines such as [Fe II] 1.644 $\mu $m and various H2 transitions in the K band. These features will be sampled with NIFS at higher spatial resolution than currently achieved at millimeter wavelengths. Studies to date show shock-excited emission line tracers can peak between the two nuclei (e.g., NGC 6240; van der Werf et al. 1993) whereas starburst tracers such as H I Br$\gamma$ emission peak on the nuclei (e.g., Arp 220; Larkin et al. 1995). NIFS will have the spatial and spectral resolution, and sensitivity, to examine these interactions in detail.

Arp 220 is considered as an example because of the availability of high spatial resolution NICMOS data for this object (Scoville et al. 1998). The two nuclei in Arp 220 are separated by $\sim $ 200 km s-1 in H I Br$\gamma$ (Larkin et al. 1995). The Br$\gamma$ fluxes from the eastern and western components are

$\sim 5.3 \times 10^{-23}$ W cm-2 and

$\sim 6.5 \times 10^{-23}$ W cm-2, respectively, summed over 200 km s-1. We assume that the flux from the eastern and western components extend over

0.2'' x 0.2'' and

0.5'' x 0.2'', respectively, based on NICMOS continuum images (Scoville et al. 1998). The emission line surface brightnesses are then

$\sim 1.3 \times 10^{-21}$ W cm-2 arcsec-2 and

$\sim 6.5 \times 10^{-22}$ W cm-2 arcsec-2 for the eastern and western components, respectively. The continuum surface brightnesses through the same apertures correspond to $K \sim 10.7$ mag arcsec-2 and $\sim 10.5$ mag arcsec-2, respectively. A signal-to-noise ratio of 10 per spectral pixel will be achieved with NIFS in the K band in 1800 s on a 200 km s-1 wide emision-line against a 10.5 mag arcsec-2 continuum with

0.1'' x 0.1'' spatial resolution at an emission line surface brightness of

5.5 x 10-22 W cm-2 arcsec-2, similar to the expected emission line surface brightness of the Arp 220 components.

A similar velocity offset is seen in NGC 1614 where the velocity separation of the two nuclei is $\sim $ 150 km s-1 with each component having a velocity dispersion of $\sigma_V \sim$ 50-60 km s-1 and together having a total Br$\gamma$ emission line flux of

$\sim 6 \times 10^{-21}$ W cm-2 through a

$\sim 2.4'' \times 4''$ aperture (Puxley & Brand 1999). Stellar velocity dispersions in ULIRGs range up to $\sim $ 360 km s-1 in NGC 6240 (Doyon et al. 1994) and have been measured successfully by Shier, Rieke, & Rieke (1996) with a velocity resolution of $\sim $ 80 km s-1.

AO imaging of NGC 3690 (Lai et al. 1999) has revealed the presence of at least six ``super star clusters'' with $K \sim$ 15.8-16.3 mag, V-K ranging from -0.4 to 1.4, and which are unresolved at 0.2'' resolution. It is unclear whether this emission is stellar or is due to ionized gas in giant H II regions. However, their existence is important because of the high specific frequency of globular clusters in giant elliptical galaxies; the possible ULIRG end-products. Globular clusters do seem to form during galaxy mergers (e.g., Schweizer & Seitzer 1998). Near-infrared spectroscopy with NIFS of ``super star clusters'' in objects like NGC 3690 will help define their nature and may provide indications of their metallicities. Measurement of their velocity dispersion relative to the main nuclei will provide information on the nuclear masses and the merger dynamics. A signal-to-noise ratio of $\sim $ 36 per spectral pixel will be achieved with NIFS in the K band in 1800 s with a

0.1'' x 0.1'' aperture on continuum objects with $K \sim 16$ mag similar to the NGC 3690 clusters.

There are no suitable OIWFS guide stars for either Arp 220 or NGC 1614 within the 120'' diameter ALTAIR field-of-view. Suitable guide stars exist for NGC 6240, and the two nuclei in NGC 3690 can be used as guide objects for each other. The bright optical cores of these objects can be used as AO guide objects.


Dynamical Evolution of High Redshift Galaxies

Using Gemini with NIFS and ALTAIR, it may be possible to probe the properties of normal disk galaxies to redshifts $z \sim 1$. The internal kinematics of high redshift galaxies are fundamentally related to the galaxy mass. Recent evidence suggests that the star formation rates in galaxies at $z \sim 1$ were up to an order of magnitude higher than in present day galaxies (Madau et al. 1996; Glazebrook et al. 1999), from which it is inferred that disk galaxies have undergone substantial evolution during the intervening period. The Tully-Fisher relation expresses the relationship between rotational velocity and disk luminosity for present day disk galaxies. If enhanced star formation in disk galaxies at $z \sim 1$ boosts their luminosities by a factor of $\sim $ 10, the Tully-Fisher relation predicts that high redshift galaxies will have rotational velocities lower by a factor of $\sim $ 2 than present day disk galaxies of similar luminosity. Measurement of disk galaxy internal dynamics can therefore be used to trace the evolution in mass-to-light ratio of the underlying stellar population, and hence directly confront theories for the evolution of galaxies over cosmic time. Vogt et al. (1996, 1997) have measured rotation curves for 16 faint field galaxies with redshifts extending to $z \sim 1$ based on the [O II] $\lambda$3727 emission line. These data demonstrate that at least some massive disk galaxies existed at $z \sim 1$. The rotational velocities for these high-luminosity galaxies indicate only a modest increase in luminosity of $\sim 0.4$ mag in MB relative to the local Tully-Fisher relation. However, evidence is accumulating that the degree of luminosity evolution to $z \sim 1$ depends on galaxy mass (Koo et al. 1995; Rix et al. 1997; Simard & Pritchet 1998), with less massive, small, disk galaxies undergoing larger evolution. Spatially and spectrally resolved observations of lower mass galaxies are therefore of greatest importance; the bulk of the star formation since $z \sim 1$ may have occurred in these systems. Confirmation that high redshift disk galaxies undergo ordered rotation is also needed, since this assumption underpins interpretations based on the Tully-Fisher relation.

H$\alpha $ is the strongest emission line in the optical spectra of disk galaxies, it is the emission line most directly related to star formation rate, and it is less affected by dust extinction than [O II] $\lambda$3727. At z > 0.5, H$\alpha $ is redshifted into the near-infrared region that is accessible with NIFS. Glazebrook et al. (1999) have detected H$\alpha $ in several $z \sim 1$ galaxies with a flux limit of $\sim 10^{-23}$ W cm-2. At $z \sim 1$, H$\alpha $ is redshifted to 1.3 $\mu $m which is accessible with the NIFS J grating. Velocity resolutions of $\sim $ 50 km s-1 are needed to adequately resolve the rotational velocity structure expected in small, low mass, disk galaxies at $z \sim 1$ (Koo et al. 1995). Spectral resolutions of this order are also required to adequately separate terrestrial OH airglow emission lines in the J band so that complete galaxy rotation curves can be recorded for significant samples of objects without contamination by OH emission lines. Spatially-resolved spectroscopy, as opposed to integrated line profiles, is essential in order to confidently interpret emission line kinematics as due to circular rotation of the galaxy disk.

Large disk galaxies at $z \sim 1$ typically have disk scale lengths RD < 6 kpc (Schade et al. 1996; Simard et al. 1999), corresponding to < 0.8'' on the sky. However, high redshift galaxies have been identified with disk scale lengths down to $R_D \sim 1$ kpc ($\sim 0.13''$; Schade et al. 1996; Simard et al. 1999), despite these galaxies having B band luminosities comparable to present day L* galaxies. These high surface brightness, small objects are the strongly starbursting, low mass galaxies that are likely to provide the best test of mass-dependent luminosity evolution (Broadhurst, Ellis, & Shanks 1988). AO spatial resolution will be required to adequately measure rotation curves for these key objects. Galaxy rotation curves are characterized by solid-body rotation out to approximately RD, and typically do not reach maximum velocity until $\sim 2 R_D$. It will be necessary to trace H$\alpha $ emission line profiles to $\sim 1.6''$ in the largest galaxies, and $\sim 0.25''$ in the smallest objects known. Due to relativistic effects, angular scales change little beyond $z \sim 1$ so the same requirements apply to higher redshift galaxies.

About 25% of galaxies at $z \sim 0.3$ have [O II] kinematics unrelated to disk rotation and have been classified as ``kinematically anomalous'' (Simard & Pritchet 1998). NIFS will be well-suited to studying the complex kinematics of these possible merger systems at high redshifts. If low mass galaxies are the most actively star forming galaxies at $z \sim 1$, they will be more susceptible to kinematic anomalies due to supernova-driven winds and nuclear outflows than their higher mass counterparts, and will present a more diverse range of kinematics when studied with NIFS.

In addition to the above physical criteria, galaxies suitable for observation with NIFS must satisfy two further criteria; they must have redshifts that avoid the strong OH airglow lines in the J band, and they must have suitable AO and OIWFS guide stars. Only a limited number of candidates can be found in existing high redshift galaxy samples. However, it should soon be possible to select samples of high redshift galaxies near bright stars using photometric redshift criteria and Sloan Digital Sky Survey data.

The performance of NIFS for these observations is affected by the lower Strehl ratio of only $\sim $ 0.2 that will be achieved in the J band, and by the detector read noise and dark current which will be significant relative to the sky background detected between OH airglow emission lines. Observations of H$\alpha $ in high redshift disk galaxies have been simulated by adopting the ``universal'' disk galaxy rotation curve of Persic & Salucci (1991). The H$\alpha $ luminosity in $z \sim 1$ galaxies is uncertain. The relation

\begin{displaymath} M(B_{AB}) = 46.7 - 1.6 \log L(H{\alpha}) \end{displaymath} (2)

between the AB absolute blue magnitude, M(BAB), and H$\alpha $ luminosity in erg s-1, $L(H\alpha)$, for z < 0.3 disk galaxies in the Canada-France redshift survey (Tresse & Maddox 1998) has been adopted, and the H$\alpha $ emission is assumed to be distributed in an exponential disk with the same scale length as the continuum light. As a test case, we consider the z = 0.9877 Sc galaxy 064-4412 for which a rotation curve has been measured in redshifted [O II] $\lambda$3727 using the Keck telescope (Vogt et al. 1996). This galaxy has a disk scale length of 4.1 kpc, an inclination of 68$^\circ$, B band extinction AB = 0.61 mag, absolute blue magnitude MB = -21.4 mag, and a terminal rotational velocity of $265\pm30$ km s-1. The H$\alpha $ rotation curve at this particular redshift is contaminated by OH airglow lines, making it necessary to adopt a slightly different redshift of 0.996. A simulated raw 3600 s exposure using the J grating of a galaxy with these parameters is shown in Figure 6. The signal-to-noise ratio in this raw image is insufficient to reliably measure a H$\alpha $ rotation curve. The noise in the image is dominated by a fixed dark current pattern expected to be present. If the dark current of the NIFS detector is sufficiently stable, it will be possible to remove this pattern without adding further noise by subtracting the median of several 1 hr dark exposures obtained during day-time. This requirement places tight constraints on the required stability of the detector dark current over periods of many hours. A dark-subtracted version of the H$\alpha $ image is shown in Figure 7, assuming that the dark current pattern can be accurately removed. The H$\alpha $ rotation curves for the central five slitlets are now seen more clearly and can probably be traced over nearly the full field-of-view using a maximum likelihood fitting technique (e.g., Simard & Pritchet 1999). No attempt has been made to subtract the OH airglow emission since this does not contaminate the H$\alpha $ spectra in this simulation. This may be necessary in real data. We conclude that it should be possible to measure H$\alpha $ rotation curves in $z \sim 1$ disk galaxies with NIFS, if the detector dark current is sufficiently stable, if scattered light from OH airglow emission lines is adequately controlled, and if the H$\alpha $ fluxes in real galaxies are similar to those assumed.

Figure 6: Central region of a simulated raw 3600 s exposure with the J grating of H$\alpha $ in a disk galaxy at z = 0.996. The signal-to-noise ratio is limited by the fixed dark current pattern.
\begin{figure} \centering\leavevmode \epsfysize=100mm \epsfbox{sim_disk_raw.ps}\end{figure}

Figure 7: Dark-subtracted version of the z = 0.996 disk galaxy H$\alpha $ spectrum shown in Figure 6.
\begin{figure} \centering\leavevmode \epsfysize=100mm \epsfbox{sim_disk_3600.ps}\end{figure}


Lyman Break Galaxies

One of the most significant legacies of the Hubble Space Telescope has been its observations of the Hubble Deep Field and the insights into the nature of galaxies at high redshift which have resulted from these observations. The high redshifts (z > 3) of many galaxies in the Hubble Deep Field can be deduced from their absence in ultraviolet images sampling the observed spectrum below the redshifted Lyman continuum absorption edge; radiation below the Lyman continuum edge is absorbed by intervening hydrogen clouds. These objects are known as ``Lyman break'' galaxies. They are among the most distant normal galaxies known.

Estimates of the star formation rates in Lyman break galaxies are based on their rest-frame ultraviolet continuum luminosities. The global star formation rate at z > 3 is quite modest and suggests that we see these galaxies before the bulk of the star formation in the Universe had taken place (Madau et al. 1996). This result is of immense significance for models of the formation and evolution of galaxies. However, the star formation rates on which it is based are questionable due primarily to the unknown and potentially large effect of extinction by dust clouds within the galaxies on the measured rest-frame ultraviolet continuum fluxes. Many paths are currently being pursued to obtain more definitive star formation rates for these galaxies.

Hydrogen recombination lines provide the most direct measure of star formation rate, and in Lyman break galaxies H$\beta$ is redshifted into the K band. Measurement of the H$\beta$ luminosities in Lyman break galaxies will therefore provide far more direct estimates of the star formation rates for these galaxies. Observations of H$\beta$ in Lyman break galaxies have already been attempted with 4 m telescopes (Pettini et al. 1998). However, the signal-to-noise ratio obtained was barely sufficient to provide convincing detections of the line. Taken at face value, these results suggest star formation rates between a factor of $\sim $ 0.7 and $\sim $ 7 larger than deduced from ultraviolet continuum measurements. This result needs to be confirmed and extended using higher signal-to-noise ratio K band spectra.

Nothing is known about the dynamics or masses of these distant, young galaxies. Moderate resolution, near-infrared observations with NIFS of redshifted H$\beta$ in Lyman break galaxies have the potential to spatially resolve velocity structure in these galaxies that would indicate whether they are undergoing ordered rotation or whether they are still accumulating sub-galactic components and are yet to settle into a stable dynamical structure. Even crude velocity measurements would provide the first constraints on the masses of these galaxy building blocks.

Typical H$\beta$ emission line fluxes for Lyman break galaxies are a few times 10-24 W cm-2. At a redshift of $z \sim 3.5$, H$\beta$ is shifted to 2.19 $\mu $m in the K band. Pettini et al. (1998) used spectral resolving powers of 2000-2500 for their observations. Lyman break galaxies are known to be small, but resolved at AO resolution, with half light radii of $\sim $ 0.2''-0.3'' (e.g., Steidel et al. 1996). Our ability to detect [O III] $\lambda$5007 and H$\beta$ at z > 3.1 with NIFS will depend on the degree to which this emission is clumped on scales matching the NIFS spatial resolution of $\sim 0.1''$. In fact, many young galaxies are composed of discrete, compact emission regions (e.g., Weedman et al. 1998), making them well-suited to AO corrected imaging spectroscopic observations with NIFS if the line fluxes are sufficiently high. If the Lyman break galaxies detected by Pettini et al. (1998) are composed of $\sim $ 5 clumps with sizes of

0.2'' x 0.2'', the typical emission line surface brightnesses of each clump will be

$\sim 5 \times 10^{-24}$ W cm-2 arcsec-2. A 5$\sigma $ detection of this feature averaged over

0.2'' x 0.2'' should be achieved in $\sim $ 2 hr. Significantly higher signal-to-noise ratios would be required to measure dynamical information. High Strehl ratios will be required to reduce sky contamination and to measure velocity differences between individual clumps. Laser guide stars will most likely be needed for objects in the Hubble Deep Field. OIWFS guide stars may be problematic for these objects.


Next Section: Context
Title/Abstract Page: Science with NIFS, Australia's
Previous Section: NIFS Core Science
Contents Page: Volume 18, Number 1

Welcome... About Electronic PASA... Instructions to Authors
ASA Home Page... CSIRO Publishing PASA
Browse Articles HOME Search Articles
© Copyright Astronomical Society of Australia 1997
ASKAP
Public